Buying a G400: Good Idea??

26 replies [Last post]
Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members

My dad is looking at changing his SWB G300D for a 2001 G400 CDi cabrio with 36,000 miles. Is that a good idea? I heard that the V8, 4-litre diesel engine and the complex electronics can be a problem with these? Is that right?

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

I wouldn't change it for a 2001. The early G400s are plagued with a variety of problems. If you care to put G400 Story through a translator it will give you an idea of all the problems Oliver had with his G400. I think after owning both a G400 and G500 he finally settled on a G300 TD.

You've got three issues.
1) Its the first year for that motor which is always problematic. They had to redesign the engine bay as the motor is too big for it normally.
2) It is heavily reliant on electronics - not just the motor but the entire G as it has a number of new features such as the command, memory seats. Again the first year these are implemented.
3) It is the first new G put out by the merger that is Daimler Chrysler and all its associated cost cutting by the bean-counters...

In short if you must get a G400 get 2005 or later. There is a reason why late model G300 TDs command more than early model G400s in Germany.

And if you absolutely must have the 2001 get a warranty and get a list of all the repairs ever done to it.

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Thanks for the reply. The vehicle has been in the UK for 2 years and before that it was originally in Germany. All I know is that the Air-Mass Flow sensor and a couple of glow-plugs were changed recently. As far as I could tell, it is fully working in other respects, but the diff input-shaft seals are leaking oil as is the engine. My dad's present G300D is 1992 vintage and leaks not one drop of oil.

I know what you mean about the MB-Chrysler era. In 2001 I'd bought a last of the range R129 (SL320), which I figured that after 13 years in production should be bug-free, but no, it was full of new electronics with no end of problems. Nice car otherwise.

With this 2001 G400, I was wondering whether it's likely that any of the big problems would have been fixed for good, after all this time? If he went for a G300TD instead, what year do they go up to?

Having had the G300D for all these years and a few 460 before that, I think he's after something with a few more toys, like in the G400. Probably the 2006 G320CDi would be the best of the new ones, but looking at mobil.de site, all the German G400 Cabrios (5 listed currently) have many more miles (>100kmiles) and/or are more expensive than this one in the UK. This one is being offered at just under £30k. I guess the £/Euro being low now makes a difference.

What mods have been done to the G400 engine bay to make the egine fit? I can see that there's not a spare mm of room in there.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

The G300TD was manufactured up until 2000 - the G400 was the replacement. But you do see a lot of 2001 G300 TDs.

I'm not 100% certain on what the mods where - I think the frame itself was modified.

It is possible the G you are looking at is trouble free (not all of them were lemons) and that's why it would be good to see the full service history. In theory if you get the VIN you should be able to go to a dealer and request it providing the work was always done at a dealer.

Personally I prefer the G300 TD. Aside from being more mechanically simpler it has a roomier interior. The G400 or indeed any 2001 or newer G has a huge console between the two front seats which I find annoying. Also the dash intrudes a little more into the cabin space.

The only things you would miss in a G300 are the large command screen (2000 G300s have a first generation system with a tiny screen on the speedometer) and memory settings for things like seats. I think the G400 may also have ESP in 2001. Oh the G400 also has climate control vs air conditioning but for me that is marginal - especially if you have a cabrio!

Best of luck and let us know what he gets. Must admit I was very briefly tempted by the G your Dad is looking at....

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Maxwell Smart wrote:
...........Aside from being more mechanically simpler it has a roomier interior. The G400 or indeed any 2001 or newer G has a huge console between the two front seats which I find annoying. Also the dash intrudes a little more into the cabin space.......

Yes, I don't like the huge centre console either, nor the electronic transfer-case operation.... nor the fact that you can't engage diff-locks unless the system says so....

Well, we'll see how it goes. I'll try to get the some details to do a service check on it. Overall, it seems in good condition, but it has seen some off-roading, as some bumps and scrapes underneath reveal and some of the paintwork, like on the bonnet, looks to have been be redone.

Thanks for the tips.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

btw - had a quick look on mobile.de and €30k (£24k) will get you a 2003 G400 Cabrio with 41k km (25k miles) as well as a 2000 G300 TD with 99k km (62k miles) in Germany.

Though of course its easier to hold James to task if you have any problems with the UK one.

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Hey, Thanks for that! (I've just seen it and looks quite good from the pics)

When I looked before, I only found 5 and they all seemed much more expensive than Jame's one.

Well, the story is that the one James is selling (on consignment) belongs to a customer of his, who wants full payment rather quickly, within 7-days and, although we're trying, it might be difficult to complete the transaction this soon, as my dad now lives in Italy.

Perhaps they have another customer, hence the rush?

Anyway, since the G400 was going to be exported to Italy, it probably would be just as easy to get one in Germany. Well, maybe not easier, but cheaper.

Thing is with UK plates, you could at least use it in Italy for about 1 year before re-registering it. Importing from Germany, I don't know?

We'll need to decide today, if we'd be able to complete on Jame's one.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

It has been around James' for a bit. I wouldn't rush. Get one in Germany especially if you are going to Italy with it.

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

yes, well the advertisement lists it as 32,000 miles, but it now has 36,000, so I agree it must have been there while, so I don't know why suddenly there's so much pressure to complete the sale.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Probably hoping he can pressure you into the sale....

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Yes, it could well be or he's go another potential buyer. But I did look again at the Mobile.de advertisement for the one at Euro-30k and the seller is in Latvia. The next cheapest one in Germany is just under Euro-40k (£31.5k) with 155,000 km. However, all of them are newer than 2001 and there's quite a nice 2006 model on offer for loads of money. A couple of years ago, I met a guy who regualarly travelled to germany to impost cars into the Uk and he told me he could easily get me a low mileage one from either Germany or Switzerland for £26k - £28k. The £ has gone down, but have prices gone up?

I'm going to take another good look at Jame's one to make sure that all the gadgets and systems are working 100%.

It has had some off-road use with some signs of bumps and scrapes underneath. It's also been fitted with ORC plates under the tank and under the transmission and the shock absorbers don't appear standard (they are red in colour).

I wonder whether anyone on this forum might know more about Jame's G400 Cabrio?

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

no it just showed up but if he has gone through the trouble to install orc protection plates then he has probably given it some pretty serious off-road.... or is just a poser.

not sure what red springs are - i think they are stiffer but someone else will know. or maybe try a search for red springs on the forum.

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Well, we've decided to go ahead with the purchase and will be looking at the car again on Friday to make sure everything on it is in working condition, and that what on the first inspection appeared to be oil leaks have been fixed.

(Apparently the ORC plates were fitted by the first owner in Germany, but there are signs of off-road use and some dents on the front protection plate.)

So, I'll have to make a good check-list between now and Friday. :lol:

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

make sure you take the VIN into MB and get a full service history. not sure if they can give you a german history as well but if not maybe call a german dealer for it.

also make sure james gives you a warranty (which he advertises the car as having a 1 year warranty). Though not sure how much good this will do you in Italy!

a little bit wary about a 7 year old car that has been used off road with such low mileage and at such a cheap price - particularly as gwagen.com is not known for being cheap!!!

caveat empor but i hope it works out for you

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Thank you for the tips (James might well be reading this thread :D ).

IIR the service booklet had three German MB dealer stamps in it, up to about 34,000 km and all looked OK, and the next two services were carried out be G-Wagen.co.uk. As I understand, the existing owner is selling on consignment through James, so not sure who set the price, but, yes, it's a bit cheaper than the other contemporary G's listed on the site.

(I know the place from some 10 years ago, when a Max McArthur used to own it, as Caversham)

With regards to the warranty, it will give some piece-of-mind, but I can't imagine bringing the car back, unless it was really something major, but then might not be able to drive back anyway it if it were really bad.

Anyway, my dad's quite stuck on this G400 now. Hopefully, everything will go well.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Well good luck and keep us posted.

Roly
Roly's picture
Offline
Joined: 07.11.2003
Location: Australia
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

I would also advise checking the relative authorities in Italy are ok with the import. I know road tax on engines larger than 2l is massive, get a quote first

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Roly wrote:
I would also advise checking the relative authorities in Italy are ok with the import. I know road tax on engines larger than 2l is massive, get a quote first

Yes, that's right. My dad currently has an older 460, 300GD, which he transferred to Italian plates, but the bureaucracy is hell (and expensive) and like you say, insurance and road-tax is not cheap either. In fact he's been stopped a number of times when towing, because the authorities want proof that the factory tow-hook is indeed a homologated, factory fitting. That was a 1986 vehicle, but maybe on this 2001 one, it will be easier to get a Certificate of Conformity.

Maxwell Smart
Maxwell Smart's picture
Offline
Joined: 05.11.2003
Location: London
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

in italy???? the land where the word safety doesn't exist?

marcus
marcus's picture
Offline
Joined: 02.05.2004
Location: Co. Antrim, N. Ireland
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Spot ( and fine ) the forigner in a RHD perhaps
Gosh why am I so cynical

mortinson
mortinson's picture
Offline
Joined: 06.11.2003
Location: Old beehive, Madrid, Spain
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Maxwell Smart wrote:
in italy???? the land where the word safety doesn't exist?

Generalizations are generally wrong!

But all the more so when you talk about Italy which in this respect is not a country but at least two!

I mean if you go to the north you feel like it's Switzerland: everything's organized and it works, people are polite and sophisticated.... and it's wet and cold :cry:

But if you go to Rome or south of Rome, he, he, he.... it's like Morocco.

Everything's disorganized and dirty and smelly and everybody is noisy and passionate. But it's sunny and warm.

And you are quite right about their driving. I used to spend a week avery month in Caserta, north of Naples. They could tell that you were a foreigner because you would stop at the red light and they would honk at you!

I miss it almost as much as I miss England :lol:

Roly
Roly's picture
Offline
Joined: 07.11.2003
Location: Australia
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

I like the speeds at which the vehicles drive. 120mph so close behind you can smell the aftershave

marcus
marcus's picture
Offline
Joined: 02.05.2004
Location: Co. Antrim, N. Ireland
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Hey Roly that is cool
Robotic controlled self driving vehicles
Or did I misunderstand :roll:
Marcus

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Maxwell Smart wrote:
Well good luck and keep us posted.

Well, the deal is done. Hope to collect at the end of the month. In the meantime, it will get an new MOT and a few things need looking at (engine oil leak and why at least one steering-box bolt has been changed and inserted the wrong-way around.) James offered 3 months warranty at first but then agreed to 12, so there should be some cover for any bigger problems.

Can anyone recommend an insurance company that's familiar with LHD, G400's ?

Arnie
Arnie's picture
Offline
Joined: 12.04.2004
Location: London
GWOA Groups: Members
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

Just to let you know that we collected the vehicle last week. Everything on it is fine except that the engine oil leak seems to be still there. It seems to be leaking from the sump gaskets but there is also a small trail down the side of the engine from the rear-right.

Anyway, tomorrow it's going in to MB to have the "lifetime-fill" auto-transmission oil changed as a precaution, as it's approaching 40,000 miles. While it's there I'll ask them to diagnose the engine leak properly. Hopefully, the worst will just be the sump-gaskets. We also found quite a few bits of interior trim, particularly around the centre air-vent and COMAND console that were removed at some point, breaking their fasteners off. So spent yesterday morning repairing these.

The front bumper appears to have been removed/ replaced at some stage since the wiring to the front fog lights has been cut and "breather" pipes to said lights are missing. (Probably used to have a winch arrangement.) Also, the front ambient air-temperature sensor and its bracket was found dangling, so if anyone can advise on where it should be attached, I'd be grateful.

Other than that the car drives very well, and is very smooth on the road, but crashes hard over any bumps. This leads me to believe that the red front shock absorbers are replacements, but I've discovered that they are adjustable, so I'll have a go at that. Probably they were tuned for German autobahns, rather than pot-holed London roads.

The chassis is in good condition, with only very minor surface rust at the exposed extremities. Not sure if the prop-shafts have ever been greased, so that will need to be done. As someone pointed out the chassis on the G400 is modified to fit the engine. This involves moving the steering box forward and out on a bracket that sits over the front transverse round tube, rather than just behind this tube as on other 463s. This means that one track-rod is longer and there is an extra cardan link in the steering column that brings it out almost horizontal and then down to the box at a sharp angle. However, the steering is precise and tight and seems none the worse for this modification.

Went to MB in Broklands, following suggestions on this forum, to obtain evidence of an immobiliser for the insurance company. It took a while to get through to the service people what I wanted, and eventually a senior service person came out to talk to us. When he saw the Infra-Red, "Smart" ignition key, he commented "...Oh yes that's the MBSS... immobiliser.... same as any Merecedes since 1998..." However, they would not put that in writing and suggested instead that I take a picture of the key and mail it to the insurance company. They also claimed that they could access data-cards for only UK-supplied vehicles, but eventually they got me a data card showing that it has an optional alarm fitted as well.

So, that's the summary to date.

shochu
shochu's picture
Offline
Joined: 10.10.2007
Location: jakarta, indonesia
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

mortinson wrote:
They could tell that you were a foreigner because you would stop at the red light and they would honk at you!

i don't understand..
why would you want to stop at the red light? :roll:

mortinson
mortinson's picture
Offline
Joined: 06.11.2003
Location: Old beehive, Madrid, Spain
Re: Buying a G400: Good Idea??

shochu wrote:
mortinson wrote:
They could tell that you were a foreigner because you would stop at the red light and they would honk at you!

i don't understand..
why would you want to stop at the red light? :roll:

Oh well.... now I see that this is not something only typical Italian :shock:

Or is it because they are all colour-blind?